Of Ash and Steel
November 6, 2025
Critic Score
60.3
15 critic reviews
User Score
No ratings
0 user ratings
Buy the all
User Reviews
No user reviews for this all yet. Be the first to write one!
Critic Reviews (15)
Graphics
35.0
Gameplay
38.0
Story
42.0
"There could be something to like in Of Ash and Steel if you can handle a lot of jank. Tristan is upset and confused as he plays the game. Sadly, you will too."
Read original reviewGraphics
30.0
Gameplay
20.0
Story
50.0
"While the game captures a certain sense of wonder, Of Ash and Steel is unreasonably unpolished and miserable to play. If the game were still in testing, I would call it ambitious, but changes still need to be made to …"
Read original reviewGraphics
25.0
Gameplay
30.0
Story
40.0
"Hugely ambitious and rife with ideas, Of Ash and Steel is an unpolished and deeply broken throwback to an era most have left behind."
Read original reviewGraphics
70.0
Gameplay
85.0
Story
80.0
"With engaging combat, crafting, and the ability to turn this simple cartographer into a worthy soldier, Of Ash and Steel became an adventure worth taking on. If you like Euro-jank style RPG’s this one is definitely for you."
Read original reviewGraphics
30.0
Gameplay
35.0
Story
25.0
"Of Ash and Steel is a big, old-school RPG that pays you for being patient, paying attention, and planning. It’s hard and fun to play because of the survival rules, the way the skill trees are connected, and the amount …"
Read original reviewGraphics
58.0
Gameplay
62.0
Story
54.0
"Of Ash and Steel is an old-school RPG in the best and worst possible ways."
Read original reviewGraphics
45.0
Gameplay
55.0
Story
60.0
"Of Ash and Steel brings to mind games like Risen or Gothic – you know, janky RPGs that were objectively kind of terrible but that sort of had their own charm, even if you had to look hard to see …"
Read original review"Of Ash and Steel is a classic tale of a zero-to-hero journey that&s;s willing to show off its flaws, intentionally and unintentionally. It&s;s the type of game that&s;s built for a particular audience, one that revels in relishing the masochistic …"
Read original reviewGraphics
75.0
Gameplay
60.0
Story
65.0
"Overall, Of Ash &a; Steel is a really fun game held back by some technical and mechanical issues. For fans of Gothic and Risen, you will definitely find a lot to enjoy with Of Ash &a; Steel. For those looking …"
Read original reviewGraphics
50.0
Gameplay
45.0
Story
60.0
"Of Ash and Steel has some technical issues that can exacerbate the difficulty, but once these are fixed, we should have a very challenging, if not brutal, Action RPG on our hands that is likely to be enjoyed by a …"
Read original reviewGraphics
38.0
Gameplay
37.0
Story
45.0
"Of Ash and Steel isn&s;t trying to be a huge triple-A adventure, but while committing to its own vision of a Gothic-like RPG, it has plenty of its own problems to sort out first."
Read original reviewGraphics
70.0
Gameplay
85.0
Story
65.0
"Of Ash and Steel is a truly fascinating world and experience that absolutely has merit."
Read original reviewGraphics
60.0
Gameplay
30.0
Story
55.0
"Apart from the frustrating nature of ‘Of Ash and Steel’s no handholding, the game is filled with bugs, and some of them are game-breaking. At the time of this review’s publication, the game is already over a month old, and …"
Read original reviewGraphics
90.0
Gameplay
75.0
Story
65.0
"This is a game for a very specific type of player. If you miss the days when RPGs were dangerous mysteries to be solved rather than checklists to be completed, this is a hidden gem waiting for you. It captures …"
Read original review