Bye Sweet Carole
October 9, 2025
Critic Score
69.3
34 critic reviews
User Score
No ratings
0 user ratings
Buy the all
User Reviews
No user reviews for this all yet. Be the first to write one!
Critic Reviews (34)
Graphics
95.0
Gameplay
85.0
Story
75.0
"Although it can be an exceptionally frustrating and unintuitive game, Bye Sweet Carole is still gorgeous and its puzzles can be quite satisfying. 🐇"
Read original reviewGraphics
68.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
78.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is a strange experience, depending on where you focus it could be an unforgettable game or a mildly frustrating mess that comes together nicely but stumbles around while getting to the amazing conclusion."
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
90.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is a different, addictive, fresh story worthy of applause in a world where taking risks deserves to be applauded. A truly unforgettable experience that proves you can do different things without needing massive budgets. Chris Darril has …"
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
75.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is a good reminder of why indie developers have a special place in the horror genre. We are faced with a game that brings a different experience of fear thanks to its own unique presentation. Relying on …"
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
90.0
"Whether you&s;re looking for a heartfelt story, puzzles to solve, or beautiful visual design, Bye Sweet Carole has it all."
Read original reviewGraphics
40.0
Gameplay
30.0
Story
60.0
"Ultimately, I admire the ambition of Bye Sweet Carole but I can’t help but feel the execution falls flat. The Disney art style really carries a lot of the game’s good will but I feel like it doesn’t live up …"
Read original reviewGraphics
70.0
Gameplay
65.0
Story
60.0
""Bye Sweet Carole is an ambitious game that shoots for the moon and ends up among the stars. The Disney-style presentation is damn near flawless and evokes a sense of childish nostalgia that hardly any game has managed to do …"
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
60.0
Story
70.0
"Bye Sweet Carole stands out for its bold artistic identity, using an innocent visual style to tell a dark and emotionally charged story. While the gameplay suffers from control issues and moments of trial and error, these flaws don’t overshadow …"
Read original reviewGraphics
30.0
Gameplay
25.0
Story
35.0
"I can’t help but feel this same sense of hopelessness at the end of my time with Bye Sweet Carole. I chased the experience of a time in the past, a nostalgia for hand-drawn animated media and some childhood-like scares. …"
Read original reviewGraphics
92.0
Gameplay
38.0
Story
64.0
"Here we are again, an absolute gorgeous game taken down a point or two by gameplay. If not for the bugs I encountered and the slowness that the game just seemed to me, this game could have been great. That …"
Read original reviewGraphics
96.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
98.0
"Between watercolor brushstrokes and screams echoing off the walls of an orphanage, Chris Darril invites us into a dreamlike fable that twists and turns, revealing its most disturbing side. A title that shines when it is silent and forces us …"
Read original review"Bye Sweet Carole may be a mix of several interesting ideas, but it wins players over mainly thanks to its attractive visuals and a well-crafted story. It&s;s just a shame that its current technical state is somewhat inconsistent."
Read original reviewGraphics
2.0
Gameplay
3.0
Story
1.0
"If you&s;ve watched the trailer for Bye Sweet Carole, you&s;ve seen the best parts of Bye Sweet Carole. The game takes a demo&a;#039;s worth of content and stretches it out over four painfully long hours."
Read original review"A bold, imperfect dark fairy tale, Bye Sweet Carole impresses with its imagery and stylish visuals, but divides on gameplay and difficulty."
Read original reviewGraphics
78.0
Gameplay
92.0
Story
68.0
"Even on PlayStation 5, Bye Sweet Carole performs admirably, with truly exciting artistic, narrative and musical direction."
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
45.0
Story
65.0
"Bye Sweet Carole delivers on the promise of a narrative-driven horror experience with the visual inspiration for classic Disney cartoons. Though it succeeds in this endeavor, it falls short of keeping you engaged with frustratingly unresponsive controls and easy stalker …"
Read original reviewGraphics
30.0
Gameplay
50.0
Story
85.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is a work that lives in its fragility – and it is precisely there, within that fragility, that it finds its most authentic power. Vulnerable,imperfect,fully aware of its limits yet unwavering in its intent, Chris Darril’s creation …"
Read original reviewGraphics
68.0
Gameplay
42.0
Story
73.0
"An enchanting fairy tale, which nevertheless "suffers" from its clumsy controls and controversial approach to the action part of the game."
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
60.0
Story
75.0
"At its best, Bye Sweet Carole feels like a gorgeous, dark adventure film from a bygone era. At its worst, it is so tedious and frustrating that you&s;ll want to demand your money back from Chris Darril himself. That&s;s a …"
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
60.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is filled to the brim with personality and style. The art and animation are something I’ve never experienced in a video game before, and it’s beautifully done. The point-and-click puzzles are straightforward, yet satisfying to solve, and …"
Read original reviewGraphics
95.0
Gameplay
65.0
Story
75.0
"Bye Sweet Carole has all the hallmarks of classic adventure games and the countless point and click games of the past. It handles horror in such a unique way due to its Disney-like presentation, and frankly, the whole experience feels …"
Read original reviewGraphics
88.0
Gameplay
65.0
Story
82.0
"Despite those rough edges, I came away impressed by Bye Sweet Carole. It’s one of those rare games that feels truly handcrafted, not just in its art style, but in the heart behind it. The visuals are pleasing to look …"
Read original reviewGraphics
70.0
Gameplay
60.0
Story
80.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is beautiful to look at, but a little tough to get through. The inconsistencies may not be enough to turn survival gamers off, but they may be too much to validate a full playthrough. If you love …"
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
80.0
"Unfolding like a classic Disney tale, this is a beautifully animated adventure that weaves a deeply personal tale. Bye Sweet Carole is driven by its art style and a brilliant musical score, but occasionally stumbles due to stiff controls and …"
Read original reviewGraphics
88.0
Gameplay
66.0
Story
72.0
"Bye Sweet Carole excels at beautiful art that echoes the style of early animation, but its tension is undermined by poor pacing and clunky controls, and any goodwill towards the spooky atmosphere is ruined by the game-crashing bug that freezes …"
Read original review"Bye Sweet Carole is a conflicted experience. The hand-drawn artistry alone justifies the asking price for those who value craft over mechanics, but Little Sewing Machine misunderstood what made childhood animation classics frightening. This would have worked better as an …"
Read original reviewGraphics
86.0
Gameplay
72.0
Story
91.0
"Driven by a striking and unforgettable visual style, Bye Sweet Carole delivers a charming, multifaceted adventure that genre fans shouldn’t miss. Clearly fueled by passion, it doesn’t achieve perfection in every gameplay element, yet it offers a memorable, emotionally resonant …"
Read original reviewGraphics
75.0
Gameplay
65.0
Story
85.0
"No small flaw can detract from the invigorating brilliance of Bye Sweet Carole, a game that finds in its obvious inspirations the breath of creativity and identity that the horror genre so desperately needs. With mesmerizing art, sound, and animation, …"
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
65.0
Story
60.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is a curate&s;s egg of a game, with the presentation being truly superb and the storytelling excellent, but the bulk of the game experience just isn&s;t fun. The frustrating platforming and stealth, combined with the review build …"
Read original reviewGraphics
30.0
Gameplay
25.0
Story
20.0
"Clearly the game is taking aim at the Disney Princess archetype, but the shots fired are all so clunky and obvious: One girl accidentally drops her manifesto for women’s liberation in front of the teacher, and later she reads from …"
Read original reviewGraphics
90.0
Gameplay
40.0
Story
70.0
"Bye Sweet Carole is a game of two minds. On one hand, it’s an artistic triumph, a breathtakingly beautiful experience that perfectly captures the magic of classic animation. On the other hand, its clunky platforming mechanics prevent it from reaching …"
Read original reviewGraphics
78.0
Gameplay
68.0
Story
72.0
"It may not come across clearly from the lines above, but I definitely didn’t walk away from Bye Sweet Carole with a bad taste in my mouth after seeing it through to the end. Even though I would have preferred …"
Read original reviewGraphics
85.0
Gameplay
70.0
Story
90.0
"You have to look at things from another perspective. A simple, overused phrase, but essential for best understanding Bye Sweet Carole. A game that must be viewed with the right sensitivity, accepting its imperfections, but also embracing its soul. The …"
Read original review